Single-Pair Ethernet (SPE) in Building Automation

Single-Pair Ethernet (SPE) represents an emerging networking technology that holds considerable potential for applications within building automation. This innovation facilitates IP-based data communication and the optional delivery of power across a single twisted-pair cable infrastructure. Initially developed to address the requirements of the automotive and industrial sectors, SPE seeks to diminish cabling complexity when compared to traditional multi-pair Ethernet systems and to furnish a standardized alternative to proprietary fieldbus systems. Its sphere of application is progressively expanding into the domain of building automation.

Technical Characteristics and Benefits of SPE

SPE employs a solitary pair of copper wires for Ethernet transmission, a departure from the two or four pairs typically necessitated by 100BASE-TX or 1000BASE-T Ethernet. This reduction in the number of conductors presents several prospective advantages for building systems:

• Reduced Material and Installation Costs: Studies indicate the possibility of reductions in the expenses associated with cabling and connectors, alongside decreases in related labor time, potentially exceeding 50% in certain scenarios. Furthermore, installation time might also see a decrease. Could these cost savings represent a significant advantage for large-scale deployments?

• Space Efficiency: The diminished diameter and lower weight of single-pair cables make them easier to install in environments where space is limited, such as conduits, elevator shafts, and HVAC ductwork. Does this improved spatial efficiency open up new installation possibilities?

• Simplified Network Architecture: SPE standards incorporate Power over Data Line (PoDL), which enables the transmission of low-voltage DC power concurrently with data over the same wire pair. This capability can negate the necessity for separate power wiring for low-power end devices like sensors and actuators, and it can lessen the reliance on protocol gateways by enabling direct IP connectivity to the network edge. This simplification could lead to more streamlined system designs, no?

• Support for Advanced Networking: SPE exhibits compatibility with standard IP protocols and can accommodate functionalities such as Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) for applications demanding deterministic communication. It facilitates integration between operational technology (OT) devices and information technology (IT) networks.

• Extended Reach Capabilities: Specific SPE physical layer standards, for instance, 10BASE-T1L (IEEE 802.3cg), are engineered for transmission distances of up to 1,000 meters at a data rate of 10 Mbit/s, offering an alternative to conventional fieldbuses or fiber optics for certain long-distance connections within buildings. This extended reach may broaden the scope of addressable applications.

SPE Application Areas in Building Automation

The application of SPE technology can be evaluated across a range of building automation subsystems:

1. Access Management & Surveillance: SPE with PoDL can simplify the installation of IP cameras, RFID readers, and allied security peripherals by consolidating both power and data onto a single cable pair. Key considerations include the expense of retrofitting existing legacy analog systems and the crucial task of managing cybersecurity risks associated with IP-connected devices. What strategies will be essential for a secure transition?

2. HVAC Systems: SPE offers a pathway to supersede traditional analog (e.g., 4-20mA) or serial fieldbus (e.g., Modbus, BACnet) connections for sensors and actuators with direct IP connectivity. This transition enables enhanced data acquisition for functions such as predictive maintenance and facilitates centralized control strategies. Challenges include seamless integration with pre-existing BACnet/Modbus infrastructure and the present level of availability of SPE-native HVAC components. Case studies emerge replacing RS485 based legacy systems with SPE.

3. Lighting Control: SPE has the potential to integrate lighting systems (potentially replacing segments using DALI or LonWorks) into the building's primary Ethernet network, thereby allowing for IP-based control and management. Relevant factors include initial deployment costs and the proper selection of SPE-compatible luminaires and controllers.

4. Fire Safety Systems: The prospective long reach and inherent noise immunity characteristics of particular SPE standards (such as 10BASE-T1L) render it technically appropriate for connecting fire detection devices like smoke and heat sensors. The rate of adoption in this critical sector is significantly influenced by stringent regulatory compliance requirements and the understandably high reliability expectations placed upon existing life-safety systems.

5. Shading & Elevators: Motorized blinds and elevator controls can potentially leverage SPE, benefiting from the reduction in cabling weight and overall size, particularly within shafts. However, for basic shading systems characterized by low data requirements, the advantages might appear less pronounced in comparison to other application areas. Elevator systems frequently rely on well-established proprietary protocols, although future demands for increased bandwidth (for example, in-car displays and sophisticated diagnostics) could favor the adoption of SPE.

Implementation Challenges

Several factors will undoubtedly influence the pace at which SPE is adopted within building automation:

• Standardization: While international standards for SPE physical layers (like IEEE 802.3cg) are in place, a number of connector designs (e.g., IEC 63171 variants) have been proposed. This situation has the potential to lead to interoperability problems and market fragmentation if a dominant standard tailored for building automation does not firmly emerge. Encouragingly, recent endeavors by various industry consortia are actively seeking to address this very issue.

• Component Availability & Cost: The broader ecosystem of SPE-specific components, including PHYs, connectors, sensors, and actuators, is still in a relatively early stage of development. The current limited availability and potentially higher initial costs for organizations that adopt the technology early on can act as significant barriers when compared directly to more established and mature technologies.

• Technical Training: Installers and maintenance personnel will require specialized training on the fundamental principles of IP networking and on SPE-specific installation practices, which differ notably from those associated with traditional low-voltage or fieldbus wiring. Will sufficient training programs become readily available?

Adoption Projections

Market analysis tentatively suggests that the adoption of SPE in building automation is likely to experience an increase, especially in the period after 2026, primarily driven by the increasing demands of IoT integration and the collaborative initiatives undertaken by influential industry alliances.

• 2025-2026: The initial wave of adoption is anticipated to occur primarily in new construction projects, with a particular focus on HVAC and access control systems where standardization efforts have made clearer progress and the advantages of PoDL are more readily apparent.

• 2027-2028: Applications in lighting and potentially fire safety systems may see expansion as the underlying technology and associated standards continue to mature, possibly incorporating TSN capabilities to a greater extent.

• 2029 onwards: With the expected development of a more comprehensive ecosystem and a subsequent reduction in component costs, the retrofitting of existing buildings and a more general adoption across diverse systems, including elevators and shading, are projected. It's plausible that SPE could evolve into a standard consideration during the network design phase of smart buildings.

Conclusion

Single-Pair Ethernet undeniably presents a technically sound and promising option for the evolution of building automation networks. Its inherent capacity to reduce the overall complexity of cabling, to consolidate the delivery of both power and data, and to extend crucial IP connectivity right to the network edge offers tangible advantages in terms of cost efficiency, installation efficiency, and overall system capability. Nevertheless, the ultimate success and widespread adoption of SPE hinges upon sustained and effective standardization endeavors, the continued growth and diversification of the component ecosystem, and the necessary adaptation of existing industry practices and the development of relevant skills.

References

[1] https://www.single-pair-ethernet.com/sites/default/files/2021-10/l-spe-whitepaperen%20final.pdf
[2] https://img.electronicdesign.com/files/base/ebm/electronicdesign/document/2020/07/SingleEthernet.5f21e4c362c6b.pdf)
[3] https://www.fs.com/blog/single-pair-ethernet-drives-automation-systemdevelopment-16379.html
[4] https://singlepairethernet.com/en/up-to-date/news/
[5] https://singlepairethernet.com/en/references/whitepaper/
[6] https://www.fs.com/au/blog/single-pair-ethernet-drives-automationsystem-development-16381.html 
[7] https://www.belden.com/blog/from-cars-to-plants-singlepair-ethernet-and-industrial-automation 
[8] https://www.metz-connect.com/home/company/newsevents/news/single-pair-ethernet-and-the-spe-industrial-partner-network.144.en.html
[9] https://www.moxa.com/en/technologies/single-pair-ethernet
[10] https://img.electronicdesign.com/files/base/ebm/electronicdesign/document/2020/07/SingleEthernet.5f21e4c362c6b.pdf 
[11] https://www.weidmueller.com/int/solutions/technologies/single_pair_ethernet/index.js
[12] https://www.single-pair-ethernet.com/en 
[13] https://singlepairethernet.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/2024-02-28__Flyer_SPE_Building_Automation_EN.pdf 
[14] https://www.icp-deutschland.de/en/news/industrial-5-port-single-pair-ethernetswitch/
[15] https://singlepairethernet.com/en/up-to-date/news/ 
[16] https://www.bihl-wiedemann.de/dk/applikationer/communication/single-pair-ethernetand-asi-5-when-and-where-does-which-technology-make-sense
[17] https://www.realpars.com/courses/single-pair-ethernetapplications 
[18] https://www.single-pair-ethernet.com/sites/default/files/2021-02/202012spe-wp-usecasesv10en.pdf 
[19] https://www.rtautomation.com/technologies/single-pair-ethernet/
[20] https://www.single-pair-ethernet.com/en/artikel/singlepair-ethernet-use-cases 
[21] https://singlepairethernet.com/wpcontent/uploads/2022/09/SPESA_Whitepaper_Fieldcommunication_EN.pdf
[22] https://www.hilscher.com/thehilscher-blog/blog-single-pair-ethernet-market-potential-and-hilschers-approach
[23] https://www.analog.com/en/resources/technical-articles/helping-achieve-net-zero-co2-emissions-with-single-pair-ethernet.html